
‘Hidden in Open Sight with Calvin Payne’ is an informative Substack by one of Sheffield’s most popular local historians.
Some time ago Calvin posted an image of a tram at the Batley Street terminus, noting that the street is now named Crabtree Close, and picked up on a refreshingly precise and helpful history-forum thread, in which a contributor ‘Waterside Echo’ pinpointed the date of the photo to late 1902. The Batley Street siding off the Barnsley Road opened in August 1902, and the tram was fitted with an enclosed top deck in 1903.
There’s a different photograph of a similar tram on Batley Street, taken from a different angle at around the same time, in Kenneth Gandy’s Sheffield Corporation Tramways (Sheffield City Libraries 1985), p 120.
Calvin was intrigued that the street had had three names – Brook Lane until 1886, then Batley Street and more recently Crabtree Close – and that the doyen of Sheffield street-names, Peter Harvey, listed it twice in his alphabetical survey, Street Names of Sheffield (Sheaf Publishing 2001), once in its own right and also as part of the collection of roads named Crabtree after the location.
I came to know about the short-lived Batley Street terminus by a different route. Once when I visited the National Tramway Museum at Crich, the Sheffield tram 74 was running with the destination ‘OSGATHORPE’.
The place-name isn’t much used nowadays, except for a little-known public park which “offers a tranquil escape from the bustling city”. Osgathorpe Road lies directly opposite Batley Street/Crabtree Close, and the 1905 Ordnance Survey 25-inch map shows the locations of now-demolished residences named Osgathorpe House, Osgathorpe Cottage and Osgathorpe Hills.
‘Waterside Echo’ refers to Charles Hall’s Sheffield Transport (Transport Publishing Company 1977) to piece together the origins of the tram route from town, along Barnsley Road and Firth Park Road to Page Hall, which the tramways department obstinately described as Pitsmoor, though it’s over a mile beyond the actual Pitsmoor.
Electric trams began operating to Page Hall within a month of the first electrified route from Tinsley to Nether Edge beginning in September 1899.
The end-to-end service was operated by single-deckers because of doubts about the braking power of double-deckers on the steepest gradient beyond Osgathorpe. The Batley Street siding was brought into use in August 1902 so that short-working double-deckers could reverse at the furthest safe point out of town. By January 1905 the double-deck cars were considered safe to run down to Page Hall, whether by an easing of the gradient or a strengthening of the brakes, and the siding was closed.
That fits with a hypothesis I’ve nursed for decades sitting on the top decks of buses travelling from town along Barnsley Road. There’s something odd about the road formation from the toll house where the nineteenth-century Burngreave Road joins Pitsmoor Road, the Wakefield & Sheffield Turnpike, which dates from 1757.
It’s possible to explore this virtually by googling ‘Pitsmoor Toll House’ on Google Earth and heading away from Sheffield: Barnsley Rd – Google Maps.
On the left, from the Church of God Seventh Day, there’s a stretch of road behind a retaining wall higher than the modern Barnsley Road. The retaining wall continues as far as Abbeyfield Primary School where the gradient dips downhill.
Then, at Crabtree Close (formerly Batley Street), on the opposite, right-hand side of the road, there is a separate elevated footpath at a higher level, which eventually drops steeply to meet the main road at the former Sheffield Companions Club, now a mosque and a couple of shops, at Fir Vale.
Presumably the present carriageway was regraded at some time for safety, but the tramway histories are silent about whether it was connected with the introduction of electric trams at the start of the twentieth century.
I often think of the novelist George Eliot’s remark in Middlemarch that “the quickest of us walk about well wadded with stupidity”.
I’ve so often sat on a bus observing these features and never turned up an answer. And if Calvin hadn’t posted the 1902 photograph of the tram I’d never have found out about the Osgathorpe grand houses, and I’d have been less well-informed about the area where I’ve lived since the mid-1970s.














